Joint Report Highlights Inconsistencies in Restrictive Practices in Scotland's Secure Care
New findings from the Care Inspectorate and Mental Welfare Commission reveal a need for greater consistency and shared learning across secure services for young people.
By Kirsty Lennox
••3 min read
AI
Generic image of abstract shapes representing support and care for young people.
A new report by the Care Inspectorate and the Mental Welfare Commission for Scotland has identified significant inconsistencies in the use of restrictive practices across Scotland's four secure care services, urging for more effective collaboration and shared learning.
The collaborative review, conducted between 2025 and 2026, examined young people's experiences of restrictive practices, including restraint, in secure care settings. The report, which collates findings from visits to Good Shepherd Centre Bishopton, Kibble Safe Centre, Rossie Secure Accommodation Services, and St. Mary’s Kenmure, noted that while many young people felt safe and had trusting relationships with staff, there were inconsistencies in practice and outcomes.
Inspectors and Commission officers found many staff to be dedicated and knowledgeable, providing compassionate support. However, the report highlights that not all young people benefited from the most effective organisational approaches to minimising and reducing the use of restrictive practices. Opportunities for shared learning across the sector were identified as significant.
A key finding was that young people did not always understand the nature of restrictions they would experience before arriving at a service. More effective communication strategies were recommended to reduce initial anxieties and trauma. The report also noted that experiencing different practice models across services was confusing and unsettling for young people, suggesting potential merit in greater uniformity across the sector.
Furthermore, there was a lack of consistent and evidenced assurance around the physical wellbeing of young people following all restraint incidents. While all services had access to Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services (CAMHS), the provision of dedicated psychological services and forensic CAMHS was inequitable across the sector.
“
"We have written to the Scottish Government to advise that research into the impact of the implementation of the Children (Care and Justice) (Scotland) Act 2024 should be considered. The results should inform all stakeholders on the strategic direction and resources required to deliver the reduction of restrictive practices within this new legislative landscape."
“
"The Care Inspectorate will continue to monitor restrictive practice in secure care services as part of their ongoing inspections. The Mental Welfare Commission and the Care Inspectorate will collaborate in 2027 to share progress made in relation to the recommendations detailed above."
Recommendations include that local authorities and partner agencies ensure young people receive accessible information about the settings and restrictions they will face. The Scottish Government is also urged to consider establishing a formal network for disseminating innovative practice and learning between secure care services and policy stakeholders. Assurance on the physical health of young people following restraint incidents must be confirmed, documented, and evidenced in care records.